Reservoir Dogs v Pulp Fiction

With the imminent release of a new Cliff Booth movie, directed by David Fincher, written by Quentin Tarantino and starrring Brad Pitt, reprising his Oscar-winning role from Once Upon A Time In Hollywood, Ross v Ross digs out one of its classic movie battles that was lying around the vault. It’s Dogs v Pulp. Between them they have ear-slicing, biblical executions and 534 uses of the f-word. It’s a bloody battle courtesy of Quentin Tarantino. Let’s go to work.
Ross McD: Reservoir Dogs
‘You keep talking like a bitch, I’m gonna slap you like a bitch’
Coolness, by its very definition, requires looking good with a lack of effort. Reservoir Dogs is a cool film: it looks good, and it looks effortless. Pulp Fiction is a cool film, but my God doesn’t it try hard. Never mind that Dogs was Quentin Tarantino’s debut film. Never mind it was made on a mere budget of $1.2m. Never mind that it is one of the most perfectly cast films ever made. Reservoir Dogs is a heist film – and there isn’t even a heist in it. It doesn’t need it. You would never get away with stuff like that nowadays.
The films are comparable – they share a lot of common components. Just like a Toyota Corolla and a Bugatti Veyron: they’ll both get you there, but one’ll do it in a hell of a lot more style:
* Vega v Vega
Believe it or not, Travolta’s Vincent and Madsen’s Vic are brothers. Like most families, you have one brother who’s older, fatter, has a stupid greasy haircut and gets himself killed after sitting on the toilet, and a younger brother who’s cold enough to torture a cop just for fun, and cool enough to stop in the middle of a shootout to bag him as a hostage – but not before stopping for fries and a soda. Madsen actually turned down the roll of Vincent Vega in favour of Kevin Costner’s Wyatt Earp – a decision that in retrospect looks like one only someone as level-headed as Mr Blonde would make. Madsen was said to have regretted it (financially, probably), but I for one am glad he didn’t. Travolta meanwhile is still trying to play the character in every film decades on. Much like Samuel L Jackson.

* Keitel v Keitel
Mr White, the deepest character in perhaps all of Tarantino’s catalogue, versus Winston Wolfe, probably the most pointless. In Dogs, he is the battle-hardened thief who has seen it all, and yet is surprised to find another facet to himself. In Pulp he is an old guy who drives so slow the scenes have to be sped up to make him look cool, and whose input is to helpfully inform Vince and Jules that they should probably clean the car and change out of their bloodied clothes. He doesn’t even bring them a change. If the boys needed to be told the above, then they were indeed both with stupid.
* Roth v Roth
A fine and perhaps underused actor in Hollywood, Tim Roth’s Mr Orange brings a fresh perspective to the undercover cop role. The emotions he briefly but convincingly portrays whenever he lets his cover down – his fear before meeting the gang he is trying to bust, his horror when he guns down a civilian after instinctively returning fire, his regret when he finally confesses to Mr White – allow us as an audience to feel relieved he is that supercool in the presence of his enemies, instead of it seeming implausible. Pulp’s Pumpkin on the other hand is just an annoying nonce with a horrible accent, guv’na.
* Buscemi v Buscemi
Steve Buscemi seems to have been in every good film ever made, as well as Escape From LA. As Mr Pink he provides some laugh-out-loud comic relief in what is a fairly dark film, despite never once trying or having to be funny. His stance on tipping, his objection to his name, his disbelief (and probable accurate appraisal) that he is the only professional in the group – literal lols. As the only person whose fate remains uncertain at the film’s close (though there was a lot of gunfire), I like to think he got away with the diamonds. For all the feckin’ good it did him – what did he survive to get cast as in Pulp Fiction? A Buddy Holly waiter cameo. Not even the real Buddy Holly, just someone dressed as him. What a croc. Shocking, Quentin.

* Tarantino v Tarantino
Speaking of Quentin, I never begrudge a director who cameos in his own films. Hitchcock did it, Peter Jackson does it – I know I’d do it. In Dogs he plays Mr Brown (who also doesn’t like his name – too close to Mr S**t), who gets to be the red ensign in Star Trek by dying for the cause. But not before entertaining the crew, and us, with his views on Madonna’s Like A Virgin – ‘dick, dick, dick, dick, dick’ – as he so eloquently puts it. So why in Pulp Fiction did he cast himself as Jimmie Dimmick (who believe it or not is related to one Lawrence Dimmick, aka Mr White), a whiny dick whose only skill is making nice coffee? Maybe it was a show of repentance for treating Steve Buscemi like that.
* Soundtrack v Soundtrack
Both films are renowned for their track listing, but I think Dogs edges it here. Girl You’ll Be a Woman Soon, Son of a Preacher Man, Miserlou – pretty good. But Stuck in the Middle With You? Coconut? I think you’ll find Reservoir Dogs has it in the Little Green Bag.
Ross McG: Pulp Fiction
‘Oh, I’m sorry. Did I break your concentration?’
I hated Pulp Fiction when I first saw it. I didn’t really get it. If Reservoir Dogs was a heist movie without a heist, here was a movie without a plot. This bold step on Tarantino’s part may not have paid off during this idiot’s first viewing, but Pulp Fiction has given so much back on the numerous occasions I’ve caught it since. Sign of a good movie: you flick on the TV and it is halfway through, and yet you can’t stop yourself watching the rest no matter how many times you’ve seen it before. Reservoir Dogs is a good film, but it’s the result of a director learning his craft, while Pulp Fiction is him honing it.
Reservoir Dogs seems to have a lot going for it. The script and the action are tight, making the movie ripe for a stage adaptation. Its premise of disparate bad guys teaming up for a job is engaging. And finally, it never shows you the heist which determines proceedings. However, these three things it has in its favour also make it flawed. Yes, it makes a great play, but its claustrophobia means it lacks the scope of Pulp Fiction, which is pure cinema. Crooks assembling for a big score is something we have seen in a thousand movies before and after the film, and magpie Quentin lifts the colour-coded names from 1974’s The Taking Of Pelham One Two Three, like Noel Gallagher ripping off a Beatles’ riff. Tarantino may be the king of homage, but this is just a blatant steal. And then we come to Dogs’ supposed trump card – the lack of a heist. Come on, admit it: a tiny part of all of us would love to see exactly what went on in that jewellery store.
In Reservoir Dogs, Tarantino is prone to cinematic ramblings – we have the overrated Madonna speech (wow, Madge likes singing about sex, who knew?) and Tim Roth learning to tell a story for about half an hour. In Pulp Fiction, however, any whimsy is controlled and comes in short, effective bursts. Jules (Samuel L Jackson) and Vincent (John Travolta) barely get into chatting naturally about burgers before they move to the equally entertaining discussion on pilot TV shows. They then slip easily into deliberating what ballpark a foot massage belongs in. The script crackles along and there is no room for flab.

It’s difficult to know exactly what Pulp Fiction is about but it is rollicking entertainment and Tarantino’s penchant for shifting the chronology of his narrative is seamless, far more assured than in his debut movie. While both films’ soundtracks are rocking, Pulp Fiction edges it thanks to Al Green and Dusty Springfield. The acting is better too. Keitel, Madsen, Penn and Buscemi shout their way through Reservoir Dogs and we don’t learn a lot about their characters. Pulp Fiction contains the performances of a lifetime from at least three of its cast – Jackson, Travolta and Thurman. Yet even those in minor roles are allowed to shine, particularly Eric Stolz as drug dealer Lance and Amanda Plummer as Honey Bunny. Heck, even Tarantino’s performance isn’t bad.
Unfortunately for Reservoir Dogs, it will mainly be remembered for that bit with the ear. Pulp Fiction, on the other hand, has scene after scene of memorable and quotable movie magic. The brilliant opening diner hold-up. The accidental shooting of Marvin. Travolta’s dancing. The syringe to the chest. Christopher Walken’s awe-inspiring watch speech. Bruce Willis taking his revenge on Travolta for being treated like a baby in Look Who’s Talking Too. It’s simply a meatier film than its predecessor (Pulp Fiction, that is. Not Look Who’s Talking Too).
Pictures: Skydance
WHAT DO YOU THINK? WHICH TARANTINO CLASSIC IS YOUR FAVOURITE?
Leave a Reply